Skip to main content
AINN NEW YORK
← Back to Top Stories

Adirondack Park Agency poised to reject Lewis howitzer testing plan

APA committee on Thursday voted to end hearing process and deny cannon testing project, before full board vote on Friday.

Adirondack Park Agency poised to reject Lewis howitzer testing plan APA committee on Thursday voted to end hearing process and deny cannon testing project, before full board vote on Friday.
people seated at a board meeting
APA committee on Thursday voted to end hearing process and deny cannon testing project, before full board vote on Friday.
people seated at a board meeting

The Adirondack Park Agency is poised to end a hearing on an application to test howitzers in the town of Lewis and reject the application on Friday.

The agency’s regulatory committee voted unanimously to accept an administrative law judge’s motion to dismiss the hearing and deny the project on Thursday, though board member Arthur Lussi expressed reservations that could impact the board’s final outcome on Friday, the second day of its November meeting.

“I’m very comfortable following the recommendation to dismiss,” Lussi said. “What I’m not comfortable with is denying it.”

Lussi declined to discuss his vote after the meeting.

The Thursday committee vote sends the motion to the 11-member board, which is slated to vote after lunch on Friday at its headquarters in Ray Brook. 

The decision could end a 5-year saga, which started when private security consulting firm Unconventional Concepts, Inc. submitted a plan to test the internal ballistics of 155 mm portable howitzers on private land in the Essex County town of Lewis. The company could come back to the agency with a new iteration of the permit application, however. 

It’s also still possible that the agency could continue with the special hearing, going against the regulatory committee’s recommendation.

Micheal Hopmeier, President of Unconventional Concepts, Inc, presenting on the proposed howitzer testing to the Lewis Town Board, at a public hearing at the Lewis Volunteer Fire Department.

Inside the debate over weapons testing in a small Adirondack town

A proposed military weapons testing range in a small town in the northeastern Adirondacks has drawn significant public scrutiny across the region.

About the project

Michael Hopmeier is president of the Florida-based company and has multiple federal contracts and owns a former Atlas F missile silo. The howitzer testing had been under a contract with the research and development branch of the military, but pulled in 2023 over safety assessment concerns of potential ricochet into state Route 9 and I-87, records showed.

Hopmeier first applied to the agency in November 2021. After six notices of incomplete application and a denied appeal, the agency sent his proposal to a rarely used adjudicatory hearing last November. Such a hearing is the only way the agency can substantially modify or deny a permit.

The hearing was intended to determine if a munitions testing facility was compatible with the agency’s rules and regulations governing the park.

The pre-hearing process has been fraught with procedural and legal challenges, most brought by Hopmeier and his attorney Matthew Norfolk. Those challenges include not allowing the hearing parties to visit the project site, suing the agency over the board vote to hold a hearing and not providing any new evidence to support the agency’s questions. Hopmeier and Norfolk also argued nearly one year into the pre-hearing process that Hopmeier didn’t need an APA permit if he were to get a federal contract for the howitzer testing, arguing the U.S. Constitution’s Supremacy Clause would negate the agency’s jurisdiction.

Matthew Robinson-Loffler, General Counsel for the APA, presenting on a motion to dismiss the judicial hearing on an application to test howitzers.
Matthew Robinson-Loffler, General Counsel for the APA, presenting on a motion to dismiss the judicial hearing on an application to test howitzers. Photo by Eric Teed

The intervening parties in the hearing, the Adirondack Council, the Sierra Club, Adirondack Wild: Friends of the Forest Preserve and Protect the Adirondacks, filed a motion to dismiss this fall. APA staff attorneys for the hearing also agreed. 

Administrative Law Judge David Greenwood wrote on Sept. 14 that Hopmeier had violated the scheduling order of the hearing, did not proceed with the hearing “in good faith,” had failed to present evidence and had thus “failed to meet their burden to show the project application meets the criteria for approval.”

APA Counsel Matthew Robinson-Loffler presented the matter. The committee includes Chair Dan Wilt, Jose Almanzar, Lussi and Ken Lynch. 

“I think what’s fair game for you is the timing, character, quality and consistency of these arguments in the context of the motion to dismiss,” Robinson-Loffler said. 

Neither Hopmeier nor Norfolk attended the meeting on Thursday.

In a Nov. 5 letter, Norfolk argued that the agency had no jurisdiction to close the hearing or deny the project, claiming a hearing had not taken place.

“Should the Agency Board consider or rely upon items of purported proof that were not formally admitted into evidence at the hearing, any resulting determination, irrespective of its outcome, would be procedurally defective and subject to annulment,” Norfolk wrote. “Undoubtedly, it will materially prejudice Mr. Hopmeier and Unconventional Concepts, Inc., and, perhaps, the other parties.”

Rush Holt, APA board member, at Thursday's committee meeting.
Rush Holt, APA board member, at Thursday’s committee meeting. Photo by Eric Teed

Norfolk has also shunned the scolding from APA staff and Greenwood, defending Hopmeier’s ability to make challenges throughout the process.

The committee also decided to accept the pre-hearing record and decided that Hopmeier had been given the chance to have a hearing, and therefore the agency could proceed

Almanzar presented the motion and Lynch seconded it. Lussi again said he supported the motion, but he wouldn’t support denying the application.

  • upstate
  • gwendolyncraig
  • adirondack
  • agency
  • poised
Read the full story at Adirondack Explorer (opens in a new tab)