Proposals sought for redevelopment of entire block in downtown Ithaca
Not one building. Not even two. No, local leaders are seeking qualified project teams to redevelop a whole block in downtown Ithaca. The request comes from the Downtown Ithaca Local Development Corporation II (LDC II), a nonprofit that spearheads development projects. The nonprofit aims to redevelop what’s known as Block 14, an entire city block […]

Not one building. Not even two. No, local leaders are seeking qualified project teams to redevelop a whole block in downtown Ithaca. The request comes from the Downtown Ithaca Local Development Corporation II (LDC II), a nonprofit that spearheads development projects. The nonprofit aims to redevelop what’s known as Block 14, an entire city block […]

Not one building. Not even two. No, local leaders are seeking qualified project teams to redevelop a whole block in downtown Ithaca.
The request comes from the Downtown Ithaca Local Development Corporation II (LDC II), a nonprofit that spearheads development projects. The nonprofit aims to redevelop what’s known as Block 14, an entire city block about 500 feet west down State Street from the West End of the Ithaca Commons.
LDC II identified Block 14 as an underutilized collection of downtown properties. It’s bounded by the 200 block of West State Street, the 200 block of West Seneca Street, and North Geneva and North Albany streets. The 1.14-acre block consists of five tax parcels that currently contain low-rise non-historic commercial and apartment buildings, storage space and parking lots.
The area highlighted in yellow is the site the Downtown Ithaca Local Development Corporation aims to redevelop. The first image in the gallery is an illustration based on a screenshot of Google Maps. Photos two through four show Block 14 and were taken by Casey Martin.
LDC II is similarly named but separate from the Downtown Ithaca Local Development Corporation (LDC). That nonprofit originally formed in 2003, was reestablished in 2020 after years of inactivity in order to construct and operate the Downtown Ithaca Conference Center.
Both projects were formed by the Downtown Ithaca Alliance, a nonprofit engaged in developing and supporting economic vitality for downtown businesses.
In its request for expressions of interest (RFEI) for Block 14’s redevelopment, LDC II included a feasibility study from HOLT Architects that it commissioned. LDC II’s goal for the block is a pedestrian-friendly mixed-use project that includes housing, commercial space and community amenities.
The feasibility study is based on current zoning and potential development scenarios. The RFEI notes that the City of Ithaca is in the process of rewriting its zoning code. However, the RFEI also notes that the LDC II expects Block 14’s multiple zoning designations to be consolidated and the property to be rezoned, allowing for a more consistently scaled, larger project.
Discussions on the block’s potential redevelopment have been ongoing for the past two and a half years. A purchase option negotiated by the LDC II is keeping the privately owned properties on Block 14 off the market until the end of December. The plans have attracted some controversy among Tompkins County officials. Legislators have sought to make clear that the county is not committed to selling its properties unless it receives a development proposal that meets its needs. Those concerns have focused primarily on parking rather than office space, which the county expects to consolidate elsewhere as it pursues plans to develop an office complex known as the Center of Government.
The county owns a pair of properties within Block 14 and would consider selling them if the redevelopment includes replacement parking for county employees. The county wants at least 74 spaces, matching its current parking capacity on the block.
Included in the December 2025 feasibility study were five conceptual analyses, ranging from a five-story project with 9,300 square feet of ground floor retail and 56 residences above, to a five-story “donut”-style building with 128 units and 33,000 square feet of ground floor retail. The residences were envisioned as primarily two-bedroom units, with a small percentage of studios and one-bedroom units.
The parking spaces provided in the concepts range from 25 to 30 spaces in some scenarios to about 120 spaces in others, accommodated by an attached parking garage envisioned along West Seneca Street. The analysis notes that additional parking could be provided by converting ground-floor retail space, but that option would conflict with the City of Ithaca’s planning goals, which deprioritize parking in favor of housing, commercial space and pedestrian-centered infrastructure.
The feasibility study noted that, as a basic estimate, aboveground structured parking costs about $110 per square foot, while underground parking costs about $150 per square foot. However, the site may not be suitable for underground parking because of flood risks.
While the feasibility study generally avoids specifics on design attributes, its intent is to demonstrate that a Block 14 project could be economically feasible and sustainable while meeting the needs and goals of both the city and county.
With that study provided, the RFEI states that submissions are expected to include housing, as well as ground-floor retail or another form of commercial space, such as a food and beverage business or recreational use. Proposals may also include community space with an eldercare or childcare facility, an appropriate amount of parking, and potentially an intercity bus hub, which the LDC II is open to incorporating into the project.
Some specific details are also provided in the RFEI. The document notes that while the high end of the rental apartment market appears to be softening, demand remains strong in the middle market. The city’s rezoning will not be completed until late 2027, so any project seeking to exceed existing zoning allowances will need to consult city planning staff. The RFEI also noted that any proposal would likely need a few years to go through the planning and review process before construction begins.
Respondents to the RFEI are expected to submit written statements describing their project team and their experience with similar types of projects, broad descriptions of their proposed projects, including conceptual uses and scale, and information about available funds and financing to demonstrate their ability to develop the site. Applications must be submitted electronically by 5 p.m. Dec. 3.
Should a suitable application be received, the LDC II intends to notify its preferred choice by the end of December. Several months of negotiations would follow, with discussions focused on the concept, financial capacity, and the prior experience and reputation of the project team. The goal would be to have a conceptual redevelopment agreement in place by the end of June 2027.
Correction (11/19/2026): Due to an error during the editing process, a previous version of this article referred to Downtown Ithaca Local Development Corporation II, or LDC II, as the Downtown Ithaca Local Development Corporation, or LDC.
The two are separate nonprofits formed for different development projects. Both were established by the Downtown Ithaca Alliance.



