New York Law School explores evolution of immigrant enclaves in NYC – and the need to adapt services for newcomers
The way immigrant communities form the fabric of New York City is shifting, according to a new report from the Department of City Planning. That has implications for the way government agencies, legal service providers and social service nonprofits need to operate and orient themselves in order to properly protect and serve the group who... Read More
The way immigrant communities form the fabric of New York City is shifting, according to a new report from the Department of City Planning.
That has implications for the way government agencies, legal service providers and social service nonprofits need to operate and orient themselves in order to properly protect and serve the group who makes up about a third of the city’s population and nearly half of its workforce that’s found itself under attack by the Trump administration.
Changes in where immigrants are calling home in the city are critical for the city to pay attention to, Faiza Ali, commissioner of the Mayor's Office of Immigrant Affairs, said of the report during a Nov. 19 discussion at the New York Law School.
“What was really interesting for us as government leaders is understanding that we're seeing growth in different parts of New York City,” said Faiza Ali, commissioner of the Mayor’s Office of Immigrant Affairs, of the report. “Some of the more established communities continue to be strongholds in neighborhoods like Elmhurst and Corona. But we're seeing the development of new ethnic enclaves. I'm in South Brooklyn, and I have … seen the population just on my block change. The numbers are really telling of a larger story of New York City.”
The report found that there are more Chinese immigrants in Southern Brooklyn and Staten Island than there have been in the past, and more Bangladeshi immigrants living across more neighborhoods in Queens than before. Longstanding major immigrant neighborhoods in Queens and Central and Southern Brooklyn — such as Astoria, Jackson Heights, Sunset Park, Crown Heights and Flatbush — saw decreases in their immigrant populations. Others, such as St. Albans and East New York - areas that typically have not had as significant immigrant populations — saw a rise in newcomers.
Ali joined a group of legal leaders, including Lisa Rivera, CEO of the New York Legal Assistance Group (NYLAG), which provides free legal representation to immigrants facing deportation or other residency-related cases, and New York City Bar Association President Matthew Diller, to discuss the new report Thursday at New York Law School.
Rivera said the data should alter the way her organization and the city government conduct outreach to ensure immigrants have the support they need if they want their services to actually reach the people who need them.
“It informs how we should be thinking about how to deliver our services,” Rivera said of the report. “Through history, certain immigrant communities have been mainstays, and we have programs, community-based organizations and deep connections with them. But, when I see this report, it makes me think about what we should be doing now and how we prepare in the next five years for the new communities that are going to be built up.”
Need to change services for NYC immigrants
[caption id="attachment_137882742" align="alignnone" width="700"]
New York City Bar Association President Matthew Diller, NYLAG CEO Lisa Rivera, Mayor’s Office of Immigrant Affairs Commissioner Faiza Ali and Planning Department Chief Demographer Eric Ketcham speak on a New York Law School panel on the report.Photo by Rochella Providence/New York Law School[/caption]
Shifts in service delivery must be made, panelists argued, not only because it’s important to individual people, but because it’s important to New York City’s continued ability to function, and because immigrants have a secure place here. That is something that the Trump administration has continued to attack and undermine with ever-changing immigration rules and aggressive Immigration and Customs Enforcement actions, resulting in more people needing more resource-intensive legal services to defend their legal right to live in the country.
"At this point, practitioners don't even understand the U.S. immigration system. Long-held practices, laws, policies, and decorum in the courtroom have been completely shredded," Rivera said. "Due process every single day is being violated in every federal courthouse across the country, and that has required legal service providers who have dedicated their entire careers to this to relearn their craft, to rethink how to argue cases ... that should not have required court appearances, much less federal litigation, such as habeas filings, and appeal after appeal. It's not just one person handling a case anymore."
Without immigration, the report found that the city’s population would have experienced a net decrease of nearly one million people between 2013 and now. That decrease could have decimated or diminished beyond recognition critical industries in the city such as healthcare, construction, transportation, manufacturing and education, as roughly half of the people employed in them are currently immigrants.
“For New York, the crisis in our immigration system is a crisis for the survival of our city as we know it,” the City Bar’s Diller said. “Targeting resources to immigrant communities is vital, of course, to the residents of our city, of course to communities, but also to the existence of the city as we know it, as a whole. That calls for a response and an awareness by all our institutions in our city because New York City, as we cherish it and love it, is really on the line in this crisis.”
Ali and Rivera said that it is not only critical that services are reoriented to meet people where they actually are, but also that they’re deployed in a way that’s culturally relevant and responsive to people’s backgrounds.
“There is not a one-size-fits-all model for immigrant communities,” Rivera said. “We have to have culturally specific, linguistically appropriate services, and ask community members, ‘What exactly is it that you need at this time? Is it full representation? Is it information about your rights? Do you want us to review papers? Do you want somebody to stand by your side when you're advocating for your rights? Do you want to articulate your claims, or do you want somebody by your side to be able to articulate them in partnership with you?’”
Another example of the need for cultural responsiveness, Ali said, is not simply knowing and providing information in the languages spoken in each neighborhood, but providing that information in the form the communities are most receptive to receiving it in.
“What’s important for government leaders is having a better understanding of the communities," Ali said. "That is what's going to inform and drive service delivery."